Not a free speech platform: Facebook declares it's a ‘publisher' & can censor whomever if wants, walking into legal trap
Added 09-20-19 12:37:02am EST - “Facebook has invoked its free speech right as a publisher, insisting its ability to smear users as extremists is protected ?" but its legal immunity thus far has rested on a law that protects platforms, not publishers. Which is it?” - Rt.com
CLICK TO SHARE
Posted By TheNewsCommenter: From Rt.com: “Not a free speech platform: Facebook declares it’s a ‘publisher’ & can censor whomever if wants, walking into legal trap”. Below is an excerpt from the article.
Facebook has declared it has the right, as a publisher, to exercise its own free speech and bar conservative political performance artist Laura Loomer from its platform. Even calling her a dangerous extremist is allowed under the First Amendment, because it’s merely an opinion, Facebook claims in its motion to dismiss the lawsuit filed by Loomer.
But Facebook has always defined itself as a tech company providing a platform for users’ speech in the past, a definition that has come to appear increasingly ridiculous in the era of widespread politically-motivated censorship. Now, the not-so-neutral content platform has redefined itself as a publisher, equipped with a whole new set of rights – but bereft of the protections that have kept it safe from legal repercussions in the past.
“Under well-established law, neither Facebook nor any other publisher can be liable for failing to publish someone else’s message,” Facebook’s motion to dismiss Loomer’s defamation suit reads, justifying its decision to ban her from the platform. It also points out that terms like “dangerous” or “promoting hate” cannot be factually verified and are thus constitutionally protected opinions for a publisher – while claiming it never applied either term to Loomer, despite banning her from its platform under its “dangerous individuals” policy.
Defining itself as a publisher opens Facebook up to lawsuits for defamation and other liability for the content users publish, something they were previously immunized against. All the lies, personal attacks, and smears launched by users going forward can now be laid at Facebook’s feet. That’s a Pandora’s box they might not want to open, legal analyst and radio host Lionel told RT.
Whatever they say – platform or publisher – their words will haunt them legally from now on.
Post a comment.
CLICK TO SHARE
COMMENTS VIA TWITTER
Not A Free Speech Platform: Facebook Declares It’s A ‘Publisher’ & Can Censor Whomever It Wants, Walking Into Legal… https://t.co/OWrsvXHSC0
Not a free speech platform: Facebook declares it’s a ‘publisher’ & can censor whomever it wants, walking into legal… https://t.co/NDXdelaI9w
RT @John_Kettler: #QAnon told us ++ago >day of reckoning coming for GOOG, FB, etc.? "They fall for it every time. Q." Not a free speech pla…
Not a free speech platform: Facebook declares it’s a ‘publisher’ & can censor whomever it wants, walking into legal… https://t.co/MCE57MlF1P
Not a free speech platform: Facebook declares it’s a ‘publisher’ & can censor whomever it wants, walking into legal… https://t.co/V6E4lCu0GP